On Thursday, November 21st, we’ll discuss: Frank Sibley, “Aesthetic concepts” and; Visual Artists Rights Act (VARA) and 5 Pointz. N.B. ALL. consideration of the difference between aesthetic and non-aesthetic concepts. The classic exposition of this distinction is Frank Sibley’s ‘Aesthetic Con- cepts’.1 . Most of Sibley’s work in aesthetics is collected in Approach to His paper ” Aesthetic Concepts” is often referred as one of the.

Author: Gukinos Fenrijind
Country: Kosovo
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Health and Food
Published (Last): 16 May 2007
Pages: 335
PDF File Size: 10.46 Mb
ePub File Size: 4.6 Mb
ISBN: 847-3-41064-996-2
Downloads: 61219
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Nikosar

Note though, that these effervescences of beauty totally independent on humankind are in the service of sexual attraction.

The position put forward by Sibley here seems pretty reasonable, and for that matter reflects similar issues I have with moral judgments. This page was last edited on 22 Decemberat To me this implies that the things are there to be discerned. If you think you should have access to this title, please contact your librarian. This leads Sibley to think that grasping properties of given items requires the capability to exercise taste or aesthetic sensibility.

Sign In Forgot password? Like Liked by 1 person. And Sibley says that it is with an ability to notice or discern things that he is concerned. Maybe you and Sibley are not addressing this issue and so are not really begging the question.

The Default Theory of Aesthetic Value. I am still not understanding your question. Topics and problems relating to taste thus became very important to Sibley’s approach, and he returned to them through his career. Sign In or Create an Account. Share this Electric content! This is very clear from his brief programmatic note “About Taste”, published in in British Journal of Aesthetics. How might I bring someone to hear the song as the outline of a face?


This is also true of natural scenes — one can think of those aesthetic concepts applicable to landscape painting and photography that also apply to actual landscape:. Aesthetic Virtues in the Context of Nirvanic Values. Approach to Aesthetics Author s: I was entirely focused on the question of whether certain claims may be objectively assessed.

Search my Subject Specializations: Also, Sibley did not see Aesthetics as remote from philosophy as whole. I used the term because it seemed appropriate to the general point not within aesthetics, but having a bearing on aesthetics I was trying to make.

It may be well acted or plotted, furiously paced, efficient at story telling, powerful that is more of an aesthetic word w.

This Week’s Special: Frank Sibley’s, “Aesthetic Concepts” – The Electric Agora

Here Sibley states the situation thus:. I found this an interesting entirely different take on aesthetics, along with evolution and sexual selection. Later he contributed another piece on Ryle, “Ryle and Thinking”, to Ryle: Aesthetically delicate, not physically delicate.

Thanks for interesting stuff. Collected Papers on Philosophical Aesthetics. Here, Frank Sibley illuminates what it is for a term or an expression to be an aesthetic term or expression, siboey. I might say, for example: And I also wanted to quote two of my favorite musicologists here, in order to indicate how important cultural context and experience really are to this issue, which classical aesthetics tend to miss or, revealing a class bias, dismiss: Purchase Subscription prices and ordering Short-term Access To purchase short term access, please sign in to your Oxford Academic account above.


This Week’s Special: Frank Sibley’s, “Aesthetic Concepts”

Robert Wilkinson – unknown. If a subculture develops an alternative, perhaps rebellious, aesthetic, they tend to replace become condescending to the old verbiage.

The problem is, one has to already have a sense that is music worthy of listening to, to be persuaded by the argument. Georges Rey – – Cognition 15 If you originally frrank with a username please use that to sign in. As Sibley correctly points sibleg, aesthetic concepts are not even governed by conditions in this loose way. The Concept of an Aesthetic Property. Frank Noel Sibley 28 February — 18 February was a British philosopher who worked mainly in the field of aesthetics. Post was not sent – check your email addresses!

Sibley also observes that we often give reasons for our ascriptions of aesthetic terms, in terms of non-aesthetic, descriptive characteristics that do not themselves require perceptiveness or taste to apply.

History of Western Philosophy. His first published paper was a long review of Gilbert Ryle ‘s Concept of Mind in Raamy Majeed – – Analysis 78 3: Bright colors may make something bold, as well as garish, but a single picture cannot have both of these characteristics at once. Kaufman Terrific piece on the philosophy of Bernard Williams https: Enter your email address to follow The Electric Agora and receive notifications of new posts by email.